Crazy Water

July 23, 2013 · 14 comments


My mother picked me up at my Manhattan office the other day so that I could take her out to lunch at a nearby faux trattoria — the kind of place that attempts to be Roman in its studied culinary insouciance, but succeeds only in doing things that Romans would actually never do, like forgetting to blanch their flowering rapini, or undercooking their eggplant, or dressing their chicory with too much acid. Lunch was pungent and biting, and when my mother stared at my head over our two iced coffees served in cheap Barolo glasses and asked if others had also noticed how white my hair appeared to suddenly be getting in spots when the light catches it just right, a knot caught in my throat and I couldn’t answer without crying, like a child; I choked on the bitterness of the meal.

Astrologically-speaking, this month was supposed to be a twice-in-a-lifetime alignment of planets and stars resulting in a fabulous period of great promise and hope fulfilled, at least for Cancerians; it was, a writer friend reminded me, also the plaiting together of three, count ’em, three, water signs coupled with a retrograde Mercury, and so when Susan and I — both of us Cancerians and me a double water sign — came home from work one night to find that a lightning strike had blown out the electrical panel controlling our well pump and the flow of water into the house, it sort of made sense, if you believe in this kind of thing. I used to question it, but then large swathes of my friends started complaining of the same sorts of water-related problems: flooded basements, burst pipes, garden hoses sliced by mowers, full water glasses dumped during dinner parties, cell phones dropped into toilets, too many tears shed out of the blue and for no reason beyond the bitter tone of conversation.

The fact of water has been everywhere;  first, it rained and rained for weeks on end, at times violently. Our local streams and rivers flooded, our gardens exploded with weeds, and foot-long worms slithered out of the earth and into the streets to avoid drowning, only to be flattened by cars; seeking safety, they found it for just a moment before getting nailed when they were looking the other way. Then, when the rains stopped and we all stepped outside to see the sun, the heat came — relentless, steaming, 100+ degree heat that made it hard to breathe, that made the world feel like the inside of a dishwasher stopped mid-cycle. I felt wobbly and unmoored, like I was on a ship in rough, crazy water.

Like I was drowning.

This has been a season of relentless discomfort that’s not so easy to write about; it can be tedious and kvetchy, so I thought instead about writing a summertime-joyful piece ending in a recipe for happy salad. But this month — these last few months — have been anything but happy salad. I’ve looked for safety and peace, like the worms, and found it for a minute — a split second of calm — before getting mashed by something else running me over from another direction. I’ve looked for sun and blue sky after the deluge, and it’s been hot as Hades. Like my old friend David Rakoff used to say, Don’t get too comfortable.

Susan’s mother, who is in her nineties, hasn’t been well now for a while; right before my book tour for Poor Man’s Feast, she’d had one in what the doctors think was probably a number of heart attacks. Since early March, there has been a passel of caregivers: the first one was taken out of the house in an ambulance (an attack of Meniere’s Disease set off by stress). The second was fired by Susan’s mother because she thought she’d be better off without her. That spawned a predictable and immediate downhill slide that resulted in a third caregiver being hired and, on occasion, nearly wrestled to the ground by my mother-in-law, who wants the car keys even though they’re not the real car keys, which we have replaced with other, non-working ones. There have been constant fits of pique; unpredictable bouts of hysteria; multiple phone calls involving cardiologists, geriatricians, social workers, visiting nurses, cousins, and the nice police officer who lives next door. There has been a serious leg gash because, at 95, my mother-in-law had to accompany the furnace man down the stairs.

The basement stairs.


So this is our life right now, amidst the relentless rains and oppressive heat and bitterness and an exploding well pump and my mother’s pointed indication that I really need to have my hair colored, soon: a nonstop marathon, from spark to flame, from fire to cinder. We’re extinguishing what we can, breathing when we’re able, sleeping if we have time, commuting five hours a day, trying to keep ourselves healthy and our own lives moving forward with our work — our book designing and cooking and editing and my writing my next book; we’re trying to cope with the fact that my father’s sister, my beloved aunt, is also 95 and we haven’t seen her in ages, my cousin Mishka had a little boy who we haven’t as yet met, and my stepmom continues to battle lymphoma. My mother needs and demands our attention and grows sullen and pouty when she doesn’t get it; our conversation grows bitter and stilted. We miss our friends; we miss our family. Some people in our lives angrily accuse us of abandoning them, when they have no sense of how deep our love for them really is. And we miss the feisty, energetic, run-circles-around-us woman who is my partner’s mother, and who is, as Doris Grumbach once described it, coming in to the end zone, kicking and screaming and fighting the whole way, god bless her.

Susan and I both had milestone birthdays this year — me in late June; she in early July — during which we stared off into the distance, depleted, angry, exhausted, weepy, needing a break (even a brief one). The only thing Susan wanted to do on her birthday was play golf at her favorite course in northern Connecticut; the hope of a peaceful three hour sliver of a day — one out of 365 of them — made her smile. So I reserved a tee time, we played three great holes, and then the thunder roared and the lightning crackled and the skies opened up, as if on cue, and we were called off the course.

Crazy water; tears of ironic bemusement, of hunger for respite, and hunger for sleep.

I keep thinking that there must be a reason for all this exhaustion and bitterness and prolonged grief, like Anne Lamott once said, after a year when everything in her life and the lives of the people she loved went wrong and started to break, right around the time that the great rains of El Nino began:

Maybe all those tears washed me a little cleaner, like an inside shower. And maybe they somehow also watered the soil beneath me. Who knows. But I will keep you posted; more will be revealed.

Indeed. I’ll be waiting.

Crazy Water 

(Adapted from Crazy Water, Pickled Lemons by Diana Henry)

The problem with feeling completely bent out of shape and undone is that it’s easy to forget to eat — at least for me. If things are particularly gnarly, I often don’t even have the energy to cook — a pox on me! — which really is the last place I want to be when I need emotional and physical nourishment. When I get to that stage, I want food that’s comforting and easy and kind: poached fish, tender-cooked vegetables, mild Mediterranean flavors all fit the bill perfectly. I’d been making versions of this dish for years and never knew that it had an official name until I bought Diana Henry’s wonderful Crazy Water, Pickled Lemons, while I was in Seattle on tour for Poor Man’s Feast.  Originating on the Amalfi coast (and called Acqua Pazza in Italian), this gorgeous dish is really too light to be called a stew, and too flavorful to be called a poach, but it contains elements of both cooking methods. In her recipe, Diana calls for very fresh sea bass; I’ve recently become a huge fan of black sea bass, so if you can find it, use it. If not, halibut or another similar firm-fleshed white fish will work just as well.

Serves 2-3

1/2 small bunch flat leaf parsley, stems and leaves separated

4 large fresh plum tomatoes, seeded and coarsely chopped (use canned, drained San Marzanos off-season)

1 dried red chile

2 garlic cloves, coarsely chopped

5 ounces dry white wine

7 ounces fresh fish stock or water

2 lbs firm-fleshed white fish, whole or filet (sea bass, black sea bass, halibut are all suitable)*

2 slices day-old baguette, toasted and rubbed with a garlic clove

excellent quality extra virgin olive oil

Tie together the parsley stalks using kitchen twine; set aside the parsley leaves. In the bottom of a medium non-reactive pan (I like to use a deep, straight-sided stainless steel saute pan), combine the parsley stems, tomatoes, chile, garlic cloves, white wine, and fish stock or water; set the pan over medium heat and bring its contents to a simmer, and cook for 10 minutes, uncovered.

Carefully add the fish to the pan, cover, and simmer for about 20 minutes. If using whole fish on the bone, check to see if its done by looking at the meat nearest the bone; if it’s white, it’s done–if it’s translucent, it needs more time. If using thick filets, slide a paring knife into the meat and carefully take a peek.

When the fish is done, remove it to a platter and keep it warm under loosely draped foil; remove the parsley stalks from the pan and discard them. Increase the heat to a fast simmer and reduce the cooking liquid by about a quarter. Coarsely chop the parsley leaves, add them to the pan, and continue to cook for another few minutes.

Set a slice of baguette in the bottom of each individual soup plate; top with the fish, and then ladle with a healthy amount of the broth. Drizzle with a bit of olive oil and serve immediately.











{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Christine July 23, 2013 at 5:19 pm

Elissa, one of my sidelines is astrology. I know a number of extremely good astrologers in the NYC area, some of whom are well known, at least in the astrological field. They might be able to give you more of an idea of what is going on, and help you to adjust to it. Let me know if you want more details.

2 doreenfinnell July 23, 2013 at 6:10 pm

Just read and reread..some things really reflect all our lives..thank you..

3 Amber July 24, 2013 at 4:46 am

The last time my mother was here she told my daughter that my lack of hair colouring made me look ‘so old’ (I am 46 and have a few grey bits). She then went on to opine that I may have lost some poundage but could do with losing ‘at least another stone’ (I am a UK size 10-12). Are you quite sure our mothers weren’t seperated at birth?? Keep your chin up. Things go in cycles and good times are never far away.

4 Emily Swantner July 24, 2013 at 12:19 pm

Oh, my goodness, I feel like you were writing this blog just for me. Thank you for such a heartfelt, real and beautiful piece. And as a bonus, you posted a recipe from one of my very favorite books!

5 Sarah July 24, 2013 at 3:52 pm

Love this. Sometimes we wish the motifs wouldn’t hit us so hard over the head, you know? Thinking of you and Susan. xS

6 Indira ganesan July 24, 2013 at 7:08 pm

So eloquently said. Rain threatens here in cape cod as i write but i will hear poems by nancy willard tonight, a great comforter. Thank you.

7 Donna July 24, 2013 at 7:41 pm

Some mothers have sharp blades. I appreciate the kind ones.

8 Margit Van Schaick July 25, 2013 at 1:59 pm

Hopefully, the promise of hope and good fortune will catch up and bear fruit–soon! As a fellow Cancer, I can say that I am indeed experiencing the amazing gift of a return to good health after 15 years of severe pain and disability. I don’t think it’s an astrological alignment that is responsible for this development. Instead, I think that the body has an intense desire to heal. I’ve had some gifted doctors, and I believe that there’s a Higher Power that watches over me. Life is truly an adventure, with good things possible just around the bend. I wish you and Susan and your loved ones all the best! Now that we have endured through this oppressive weather,(climate change seems to have arrived full force here in Vermont!), perhaps pain and sorrow will take a leave along with the heat and humidity.

9 Elissa July 25, 2013 at 2:10 pm

Thank you so much Margit-

10 Karen July 25, 2013 at 3:34 pm

Strange weather in London too. Freezing winter, cold, wet early summer and now the longest heatwave in almost 20 years and it feels like the Med. But the rains are predicted and I’m facing a milestone birthday in a couple of weeks too (starts with a 4!) so I feel for you. I hope all is as well as it can be with Susan’s mother and glad you are remembering to eat. I have cooked that Crazy Water recipe from Diana Henry’s book many times, it is particularly good in hot weather but am glad to see the inclusion of the baguette. I feel it NEEDS carbs to mop up all that juice and oil but had never thought to actually include them in each bowl. Delicious!

11 Ann July 26, 2013 at 7:25 am

I hope that your relentless discomfort is easing up by now and that there are days of promise and hope ahead. I appreciate the candor with which you have written this post, and can certainly relate. When life feels like a bad restaurant, head for your favorites and dine repeatedly until you are reminded of the good!

12 Pamela Duran July 27, 2013 at 6:45 am

My mother was so enraged when I let my hair go gray in my 50’s that she kept threatening to tell people that I was her mother. I finally stopped that by saying, “if you do that, I will tell them you have Alzheimer’s, and now think I am your mother.” End of discussion.
Now, ten years later, I have cut off all communication with her, because she is toxic.

13 brenda July 27, 2013 at 11:51 pm

thanks so much for this piece — so sorry you guys are struggling — hope you find your balance — in the meantime, you grace all of us with your lovely writing — LOVE your dishwasher analogy — I live in Houston and it’s like that all summer — when you have a down moment, just remember that things could be worse…you could live in TX! LOL

14 Andrea August 15, 2013 at 2:54 pm

Thank you for your post. It seems our generation is taking care of our parents and not finding enough time to care for ourselves. We look after my 104 yo mother in law who still lives in her own home and regularly fires or threatens to fire her very professional and tireless caregivers. I know in my heart my daughter who is a wonderful person will not take care of us like this when and if we need it. Nor do I want her to as I don’t want to live so long that people forget what an interesting person I used to be.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:



©2009, ©2010, Poor Man's Feast. All rights reserved. To reprint any content herein, including recipes and photography, please contact